 |
Living with HIV: An exploration of the work-related experiences of those living with HIV in Nova Scotia, Canada
Jacqueline Gahagan, Laurene Rehman and Larry Baxter
Abstract
Objective: To explore workplace and related experiences and perceptions of a sample of HIV-positive individuals living with HIV in Nova Scotia, Canada in order to further explicate the impact of workplace and disability policies on back to work issues.
Methods: This qualitative, exploratory study used in-depth interviews with a sample of 20 HIV-positive individuals living in Nova Scotia to contextualize work- and policy-related tensions that influence back to work decisions. Thematic analysis was conducted with the verbatim transcripts to determine the key issues influencing back to work decisions among the participants.
Results: Both personal and broader structural factors appear to contribute to the complex decision to return to work or to remain outside the paid workforce, including financial status, social support, isolation, workplace stigma and discrimination, and fear of losing work-related benefits.
Conclusions: There is a need for ongoing analyses of workplace and related policies that may inhibit or facilitate the potential to reenter the paid workforce among those living with HIV in Nova Scotia. Enhanced awareness among policy makers, employers and organizations is needed to address the tensions associated with workplace demands versus those experienced when living with HIV infection.
Introduction
With the emergence of new medications to help delay the development of full-blown AIDS among those living with HIV came the contentious and disputed reconceptualization of the disease as a long-term chronic, yet manageable illness enabling individuals to return to or continue with paid employment or education and training (Adam & Sears, 1996; Ferrier & Lavis, 2003; Husbands, 2003; Jalbert, 1998; Pierret, 2000). While the cyclic nature of the illness may allow for the reentry into the paid workforce during periods of wellness, the often-times linear, all-or-nothing approach to workplace and related income support and vocational rehabilitation policies must be addressed (Cummings, 1996; Maticka-Tyndale, Adam, & Cohen, 2002; Nixon, 2003; Shaw, Segal, Polatajko, & Harburn, 2002).
Although HIV continues to be cited in the literature as a long-term, chronic yet manageable illness, the uncertain and variable illness trajectory, along with the stigma and discrimination often experienced by people living with HIV/AIDS requires income support policies and vocational rehabilitation programs to be more flexible, equitable and accessible. This is particularly the case in smaller provinces in Canada such as Nova Scotia where HIV-related services and programs are often centrally located in the largest urban centre and thereby less accessible to those in more rural areas. With a total population of less than one million and where over half the population live outside the Halifax regional municipality (Statistics Canada, 2003), Nova Scotia faces a number of unique challenges in addressing the needs of those living with HIV/AIDS. In addition, the relatively low numbers of both HIV positive test results and AIDS cases in Nova Scotia as compared to the rest of Canada (Public Health Agency of Canada, 2004) presents challenges in sustaining HIV/AIDS awareness efforts in all sectors, including income support policies and vocational rehabilitation programming. Without addressing these various challenges we will likely to see a continued and unresolved tension between the reality of living with HIV and the policies that are meant to provide needed income support for those in times of unemployment (Brook, & Klosinski, 1999). These tensions have not been previously examined using a qualitative, exploratory methodology with HIV positive individuals living and working in Nova Scotia, Canada.
The purpose of this research was therefore to explore in an open-ended, qualitative, conversational format the key question of how a sample of people living with HIV/AIDS in Nova Scotia, Canada perceived barriers to remaining in or returning to the paid workplace, school or disability pension. This paper provides an opportunity for the lived experiences of a sample of HIV positive individuals living in Nova Scotia to be heard in relation to these critical issues. This study grew out of the recognition that increasing numbers of people with HIV are living longer lives due, in part, to the advent of highly active anti-retroviral therapies (HAART) and that this may in turn call into question current approaches to disability policies in Canada. Further, as stated in the Strategic Directions of the Nova Scotia Strategy on HIV/AIDS (2003), there is an urgent need to "build a coordinated approach to care, treatment, and support services, along with an examination of the guidelines for insurance coverage of HIV/AIDS cases including illness/disability benefit policies and programs, third party insurance coverage, and the appeal process" (p.24).
Methods
Following approval of the research protocol by the Dalhousie University ethics review board, qualitative, open-ended, in-depth interviews were conducted with a sample of 20 HIV-positive individuals living in Nova Scotia, Canada to explore their experiences with back to work issues and associated vocational rehabilitation and disability policies. The use of open-ended, qualitative, exploratory methods rather than closed-ended quantitative methods were seen as most appropriate to help guide our understanding of the complex contextual issues associated with both the perceptions and lived experiences of a sample of individuals living with HIV/AIDS. The purpose of such qualitative approaches is not to generalize to the broader population of people living with HIV/AIDS in Nova Scotia or in Canada more broadly, but rather to provide contextual data from a sample of individuals with HIV relative to their workplace related experiences. As such, the only quantitative data gathered for this study were in the form of a brief demographic survey (Refer to Table II for Demographic Characteristics).
Individuals were referred to the study through a variety of community-based AIDS Service Organizations (ASOs) and sexual health agencies throughout Nova Scotia that agreed to post and circulate a notice about the study in their offices. A convenience sampling strategy with specific selection criteria was used for this study. Interested individuals were asked to call the principal investigator to determine eligibility and to schedule an interview at a time and location most convenient to the participant (Refer to Table I for Inclusion Criteria). The selection criteria were based on the need to ensure that all participants had previous or current paid workforce experience in order to elicit their responses to interview questions which were focused on the potential disconnects between disability policies and practices. Approximately half of the interviews took place in the office of the principal investigator, while the remainder of the interviews took place in a private meeting room in a local AIDS Service Organization (ASO).
All interviews were audio-taped with the permission of the participants and were transcribed verbatim and lasted, on average, 1.5 hours. The data were managed using QSR NUD*IST and were analyzed inductively by exploring emergent themes, patterns, and categories (Patton, 2002). This analytic approach involved a constant search for negative or contradictory examples in the data in an attempt to ascertain rival explanations. In addition, an audit trail was maintained throughout the data collection and analysis processes to assist with transparency and transferability. The key emergent themes included: 1.issues related to personal factors in back to work related decisions; 2. broader structural factors that permeated the participants' accounts when describing the tensions between feeling well enough to return to work; and 3. fear regarding the perceived or actual loss of disability pension benefits. The following section offers an overview of each of these emergent themes and related sub-themes based on the participants' accounts.
Table I Inclusion Criteria
|
1. Living with HIV infection for a minimum of one year.
|
|
2. Currently living in Nova Scotia
|
|
3. Paid workforce experience in Nova Scotia prior to HIV diagnosis
|
|
4. Ability to speak and understand English
|
|